What does it take for scientists to push beyond the current limits of knowledge? Researchers in Federico Capasso’s group at the Harvard John A. Paulson School of Engineering and Applied Sciences (SEAS) have developed an effective formula.

“Dream big, question everything we know, question the textbooks,” says Vincent Ginis, a visiting professor at SEAS and first author of a new paper reporting a breakthrough in optical resonator technology. “That’s how Federico asks our lab team to work together. He challenges us to rethink all the classical rules to see if we can make devices do things better and in novel ways.”

That approach led to the team’s latest result, an optical resonator capable of manipulating light in never-before-observed ways. The breakthrough could influence how resonators are understood and open doors for new capabilities.

“This is an advance that alters fundamentally the design of resonators by using reflectors that convert light from one pattern to another as it bounces back and forth,” says Capasso, the Robert L. Wallace Professor of Applied Physics and Vinton Hayes Senior Research Fellow in Electrical Engineering at SEAS.

Optical resonators play a key role in many aspects of modern life.

“Resonators are central components in most applications of optics, lasers, microscopy, sensing—they appear in all of these technologies as essential building blocks,” says Ginis, who is also an assistant professor of mathematics and physics at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel. “They consist of two reflectors that bounce light back and forth, concentrating light in lasers for example, or filtering out frequencies of light such as in fiber optics and telecommunications.”

Optical resonators are key to telecommunications transmissions, encoding images and audio through frequencies of light.

“Each message, to keep separate from the others, is encoded on its specific frequency,” Ginis says. “Resonators allow us to ‘tape off’ exact, unique frequencies to allow many different messages to be transmitted simultaneously.”

Until now, resonators and the two reflective mirrors inside them controlled the intensity and frequency of light, but not the mode of light, which determines the shape and manner in which photons flow through space and time. We often think of light as moving in a beam like a straight line, but beams of light are also capable of traveling in other modes, like spirals. The new optical resonator developed by Capasso’s team is the first such device that gives scientists precise control over the mode of light, and even more importantly, enables multi-mode coupled light to exist within the resonator.

The team achieved this by etching a new type of pattern on the surface of the reflectors at each end of the resonator device.

“We realized that we could test our novel resonator concept in an integrated photonics platform, and chose silicon-on-insulator, which is used by many scientists and companies for applications such as sensing or communications,” says Cristina Benea-Chelmus, a research associate in the Capasso group and assistant professor of microengineering at the EPFL Institute of Electro and Microengineering, who spearheaded the experimental part of the work.

The etchings, about 300-600 nanometers in size, gave the team control over the shape of light beams inside the resonator. Using reflectors with different patterns on either end of the resonator unlocked their ability to change the shape of light as it moves.

“We can make these light modes play with each other, turning one mode into another, and then back into the first mode, creating loops of different light modes moving through the same space,” Ginis says. “When we saw this, we realized we were in ‘terra incognita’ here.”

Combining more than one mode of light creates what the researchers called a “supermode.”

“In traditional resonators, as light moves back and forth, the mode is always the same—the properties of light are always symmetric,” he says. “In ours, as the light goes from left to right or right to left, the modes are different. We’ve figured out how to break symmetry inside a resonator.”

“Having multimode control of light will have a huge impact on the bandwidth of information that can be transmitted using light,” he says. “It opens up many channels of transmission that we haven’t been able to access simultaneously until now.”

The Capasso team’s optical resonator provides a new tool to conduct fundamental physics experiments, including optomechanics, using light to make things move.

“By placing an object inside a resonator, you can manipulate materials like tiny atoms, molecules, and strands of DNA,” Ginis says. The new device, with its supermode capabilities, could unlock new degrees of freedom for researchers to manipulate minuscule materials with different shapes of light beams.

“By questioning the foundations of textbook resonator theory, we have discovered completely new and counterintuitive properties of light not found in traditional resonators,” Capasso says. These properties, including “mode-independent resonances and directionally dependent propagation,” unlock unforeseen opportunities for photonics, acoustics, and beyond, he adds.

Harvard’s Office of Technology Development has protected the intellectual property arising from the Capasso Lab’s optical resonator innovations and is exploring commercialization opportunities.

Additional authors include postdoctoral fellow Jinsheng Lu and research associate Marco Piccardo.

This work was supported by the Air Force Office of Scientific Research (grants FA550-19-1-0352 and FA95550-19-1-0135), the Research Foundation Flanders, and the Hans Eggenberger Foundation. This work was performed in part at the Center for Nanoscale Systems (CNS), a member of the National Nanotechnology Coordinated Infrastructure Network (NNCI), which is supported by the National Science Foundation under NSF Award no. 1541959.

When a Southwest Research Institute scientist discovered surprising evidence that Saturn’s smallest, the innermost moon could generate the right amount of heat to support a liquid internal ocean, colleagues began studying Mimas’ surface to understand how its interior may have evolved. Numerical simulations of the moon’s Herschel impact basin, the most striking feature on its heavily cratered surface, determined that the basin’s structure and the lack of tectonics on Mimas are compatible with a thinning ice shell and geologically young ocean.

“In the waning days of NASA’s Cassini mission to Saturn, the spacecraft identified a curious libration, or oscillation, in Mimas’ rotation, which often points to a geologically active body able to support an internal ocean,” said SwRI’s Dr. Alyssa Rhoden, a specialist in the geophysics of icy satellites, particularly those containing oceans, and the evolution of giant planet satellite systems. She is the second author of a new Geophysical Research Letters paper on the subject. “Mimas seemed like an unlikely candidate, with its icy, heavily cratered surface marked by one giant impact crater that makes the small moon look much like the Death Star from Star Wars. If Mimas has an ocean, it represents a new class of small, ‘stealth’ ocean worlds with surfaces that do not betray the ocean’s existence.”

Rhoden worked with Purdue graduate student Adeene Denton to better understand how a heavily cratered moon like Mimas could possess an internal ocean. Denton modeled the formation of the Hershel impact basin using iSALE-2D simulation software. The models showed that Mimas’ ice shell had to be at least 34 miles (55 km) thick at the time of the Herschel-forming impact. In contrast, observations of Mimas and models of its internal heating limit the present-day ice shell thickness to less than 19 miles (30 km) thick, if it currently harbors an ocean. These results imply that a present-day ocean within Mimas must have been warming and expanding since the basin formed. It is also possible that Mimas was entirely frozen both at the time of the Herschel impact and present. However, Denton found that including an interior ocean in impact, models helped produce the shape of the basin.

“We found that Herschel could not have formed in an ice shell at the present-day thickness without obliterating the ice shell at the impact site,” said Denton, who is now a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Arizona. “If Mimas has an ocean today, the ice shell has been thinning since the formation of Herschel, which could also explain the lack of fractures on Mimas. If Mimas is an emerging ocean world, that places important constraints on the formation, evolution, and habitability of all of the mid-sized moons of Saturn.”

“Although our results support a present-day ocean within Mimas, it is challenging to reconcile the moon’s orbital and geologic characteristics with our current understanding of its thermal-orbital evolution,” Rhoden said. “Evaluating Mimas’ status as an ocean moon would benchmark models of its formation and evolution. This would help us better understand Saturn’s rings and mid-sized moons as well as the prevalence of potentially habitable ocean moons, particularly at Uranus. Mimas is a compelling target for continued investigation.”