INDUSTRY
HP's PA-RISC to Intel Itanium Migration Plan Questioned by IT Industry Analyst
CONCORD, Mass. -- HP customers considering migrating from an HP 9000 PA-RISC environment to an Intel Itanium environment may encounter a few "surprises." Just as Intel announces it newest version of its Itanium 2 architecture, technology analysis firm Clabby Analytics issued a ten-page report (called "HP's Forced Migration to Itanium", see: www.valleyviewventures.com) questioning Hewlett-Packard's plans for migrating its large PA-RISC user base to Itanium architecture. "Moving PA-RISC applications to Itanium and achieving increased performance will not be as painless as IT managers may think," says Joe Clabby, President of Clabby Analytics.
Some of the report highlights include:
1) Clabby Analytics believes that HP customers considering migrating from
an HP 9000 PA-RISC environment to an Intel Itanium environment are in
for a few "surprises." Such as:
a) Performance improvements in custom applications are not likely when
moving to Itanium, even with HP's binary compatibility claim because
RISC applications will be run differently on Itanium EPIC
architecture;
b) Emulation mode performs poorly today (although HP is working with
Intel to improve this) -- but IT managers usually shy away from
running applications on emulators; and,
c) IT buyers may have to wait (years?) until their packaged
applications can run on EPIC architecture because very few packaged
applications(around 300) are available on Intel's new EPIC
architecture (the explicitly parallel instruction computing
architecture that drives Itanium).
2) Clabby Analytics thinks that the point in migrating is to achieve
performance - and moving custom RISC code to Itanium does not
necessarily enable HP customers to achieve any performance benefits.
3) HP customers may be better off moving to another RISC architecture such
as SUN's UltraSPARC (12,000 applications) or IBM POWER (16,000
applications) in order to secure a RISC growth path on proven RISC-
based technologies.
4) Given HP's poor positioning in business process reengineering
professional services and its declining headcount, Clabby Analytics
questions whether HP PA-RISC customers should continue to consider HP
their strategic partner.